ERA Office: Monday – Friday 9:00-5:00 CST

275 W. BROWN ST, UNION, MO 63084

636-584-7400

office@electricalrebuilders.org

ERA Tech Helpline: 636-584-TECH (8324)

Examining Cash for Clunkers: The good, the bad, and the wait-and-see By Traci Matt Associate Editor hey rallied against it like a “Who’s Who” of acronyms—the Automotive Parts Remanufacturers Association (APRA), the Specialty Equipment Market Association (SEMA), the Engine Builders Association (AERA), Automotive Warehouse Distributors Association (AWDA), Automotive Aftermarket Industry Association (AAJA), Automotive Transmission Rebuilders Association (ATRA) and even the Tire Industry Association (TIA)—all joined forces to protest the federally- funded car scrappage program dubbed Cash for Clunkers. The bill, which was signed into law by President Obama at the end of June, is simple enough. About ten pages long, Title XIII, the Consumer Assistance to Recycle and Save Program, Car Allowance Rebate System, or C.A.R.S., appropriates $1 billion in federal money to offset the purchase or lease price of “new fuel efficient” vehicles when less fuel efficient models are traded in. At this time, the “fleet modernization” program is scheduled to go through November 1 of this year, although exten- sion discussions began before the final rollout details were even announced. Proponents tout it as a way to help reduce dependence on foreign oil, benefit the environment, and stimulate the econ- omy. Opponents have charged it with being everything from a waste of tax dollars ($50 million alone is earmarked for program administration), to a thorn in the side of the aftermarket, to another destructive force on the already debt- burdened middle class. (Remember the mortgage debacle caused by America’s overspending on housing?) APRA President Bill Gager said at this early stage the program’s impact on rebuilding is “unknown” and the reduc- tion in pollution will be negligible because most clunkers are not driven much anyway. “We always thought it would be detri- mental because it would remove cores from circulation. Hard to know how many cars will really be traded in,” he said. “Will folks really get rid of their clunker which is probably paid for and take on a four-or five-year loan? I personally don’t think So.” Gager said a better alternative for the aftermarket would have been if the bill had included some sort of repair option. “The politicians who come up with these grandiose ideas think they sound ter- rific and make sense. In reality they are a bust. Unfortunately politicians pay atten- tion to academics and think-tank folks and not the real people that are in the industry affected. The group that gets hurt the most is the American taxpayer,” he said. Perhaps in this rare instance the media has become a calming influence on the initial panic which ensued in the aftermar- ket when the program was announced. Reuters reported that the program’s “short duration and various eligibility rules” will limit its impact, and CNN Money reported that the law will benefit few and “those who might actually benefit from it proba- bly shouldn’t be buying a new car to begin with.” Rebuilder Rob Robinson of Auto Start in Lewisville, Texas, said he doesn’t think C.A.R.S. will affect the rebuilding supply chain. “Actually I don’t think this program will last very long. The $3,500 to $4,500 incentive money is not going to help too many people. I think the audience that this is intended for is already struggling to make ends meet and watching every penny being spent. I find it almost laugh- able that someone in government would think these people will go out and buy a new car. The car dealerships are already giving buying incentives with reduced prices and zero interest for 60 months and they are still not selling many cars so how is this Cash for Clunkers any different,” said Robinson. He is particularly incensed that the American car manufacturers are being additionally undergirded with tax dollars through the program. “I have managed to take care of my bottom line by cutting costs and doing without, I will never see a nickel’s worth of help from the government to help pay my bills. This Cash for Clunkers policy is just another slap in the face of the hard work- ing owners and our employees,” he said. Aaron Tobin of Global Remanufac- turing in Roseville, Ill., said Cash for Clunkers is “shockingly bad legislation for many reasons,” including the trade of slight emissions reduction for more scrap in landfills and “pollutants created by tear- ing down and melting down perfectly good cars and their components.” He said it will also boost China’s economy, not ours. “When these good cars are scrapped out, the good metal will not go into land- fills, but will be sold to China at ridicu- lously low prices, and then come back as cheap consumer products, again hurting our economy,” he said. “This bill is going to do tremendous damage to the auto parts industry and to the remanufacturing industry. With all the new cars on the road, people will not need to buy parts for them. This will end up hurting our economy with all the job cuts at auto parts manu

File Type: pdf
File Size: 3 MB
Categories: eren